When brand new, my Colt Commander .45 did not like American Eagle at all ! Would not fully go into battery reliably.
Every other mfg I tried worked fine, including reloads the range sold.
Before that my new Ruger AR 556 had feeding / ejection problems; a round got stuck, blew out the mag and cracked the BCG! Not hurt, but VERY surprised. And Ruger replaced my AR just before the initial compliance ban in CA, Jan 2016.
So - Largely based on several comments from knowledgeable folks and LEOs, I also completely stopped using reloads.
Don't know for sure, but have never bought 45 cal. American Eagle since for my Colt. Have used their 9mm and 223 without any problem though.
Now I only buy new mfg ammo, and research, and ask questions. (More knowledge early on might have helped.)
No two guns are the same - and experiences vary. Just be careful having fun!
=)