Well since the original thread is over a year old, but people are still making suggestions, I'll add mine.
I've had 22 1911s since 1996. Some got sold off with less than a hundred rds through them, others I shot thousands. I currently have 13 1911s in different calibers 9mm, .45 and a 10mm.
I have Tisas, Colt, Springfield Armory, Alpha Foxtrot, and Kimber currently. The Kimber is a Custom shop without Swartz safety. It is fine and works great. I don't like the series II. I have owned a Baer for a short time, and many other Soringfields. I've never sold a Colt. I do all of my own fitting and adjustments.
Here is what my 30 yr experience with 1911s have taught me.
Top level semi custom 1911s
Alchemy, Nighthawk, Wilson
Below that line
Colt Custom shop
Springfield Custom (used market)
Sub 2000
TRP
Springfield Master Class series (used)
Colt Combat Elite
Kimber Custom Shop (no series II)
(I own all of these)
Sub 1200
Colt Competition series
Springfield Ronin
Bul Armory (very good fit)
Springfield Garrison (nice old school look with modern features)
Tisas seem to be the best sub 600 but I wouldn't buy one more than that. I've had three and all three needed extractor adjustment and sight adjustment. The bushings are also very loose and groups are pretty big compared to my Colts and SA.
I would never buy a Taurus 1911 and would throw it in a lake somewhere so no one I knew could shoot it if someone gave me one.
The S and W seems to be ok but I'm just not a fan of external extraction or Smith and Wesson. Not a fan of Sig or Rugers either.
The recommended brands above are probably the only ones I would consider at this stage in my life. Good luck.