Brother, I feel your pain, I have been shooting heavy metal with my 870 and I can tell you I went home with blood on me. I have gotten the same response from almost everyone about fixing it up, the "buy a different gun" solution doesnt really sit well with me, sort of feels like, I dont like it or dont want to learn how to fix it so piss up a rope. I know it CAN be fixed, will some finish suffer, yea, but Id rather have a little finish rubbed off then come home missing a thumbnail. I guess Im just a stubborn SOB but I really do like my 870, I like the way it looks and feels. Its not the easiest to shoot compared to some of the others, but Im not here to give myself the easiest ride available. I WANT to work for it. So I guess Im just weird, Im on the verge of doing some work to mine and Im less worried about the finish, so if you want, Ill take the plunge and let you know how it works out for me.