I don't think that a GD discussion area is necessary at all. In fact, maybe that's why OSA is down so much, bandwidth required by the GD section, lol.
Just for comparison, I crunched numbers of all the comparative forums(less the marketplace section) on OSA, and came up with a total of 21k threads. The GD section alone has 35k threads, how awesome would it be if those discussions were more information in the gun threads? You wouldn't have time to read the GD thread, because you'd more than likely be learning too much in the gun threads.
If it were like that, it would be beneficial to have individual gun type threads, clustered in a maker forum(i.e. forum/Remington/700) so that you could go straight to the gun you were trying to find out about and read through it for an answer before you even asked the question.
I mean, I know there's a lot of gun models, but 90% of the time the questions are still about one class of gun.
Also, lest we forget, look at the FGST thread. 53k replies. 53, 0 0 0. In one thread. I tried making sense of it one time after I joined OSA, then I woke up later with drool down my shirt. Apparently I had blacked out, I don't know.
I don't think we need non-gun stuff like that here. I'm not even a good contributor here, as I don't competitively shoot, but I come here first to ask a question, as it's easier for me to find the right forum. More than likely, it won't get moved without a little heads up if I accidentally get it in the wrong forum.
I'm just saying. . .