I love the .17HMR!

dennishoddy

Moderator
Joined
Feb 11, 2011
Messages
11,958
Location
Ponca City, Ok
I've got the Savage 93R17 stainless bull barrel, with laminated stock. Topped it with a Nikon Buckmaster 3X9 a couple of years ago. This little cartridge just puts small game to sleep. They don't move after being shot. :D

racoon came in the yard Friday, and started chasing the dogs. He was acting totally weird. I got the rifle, got the dogs out of the way, and popped him....went to sleep.
Skunk came through the yard tonight. I let him get 75 yds out in the pasture, east of the house, and he just went to sleep....

Anybody else have one of these fun guns?

photo-2.jpg
 
Register to hide this ad
I love my Marlin 917V.
I use it around the house for pest control.
I've killed several coyotes with it in the yard, which makes me a pariah with the "experts".

Shot placement and bullet selection (20 gr XTP) is everything if you go that big.

hmryoteright.jpg
 
I've always wanted to dabble in the tiniest rifle rounds. And now that I have an AR, I suppose I am, but the .17 caliber cartridges are just interesting.
 
I love my Marlin 917V.
I use it around the house for pest control.
I've killed several coyotes with it in the yard, which makes me a pariah with the "experts".

Shot placement and bullet selection (20 gr XTP) is everything if you go that big.


the new Hornady 20 grain is what to use for anything bigger than a Raccoon.

A little history on the .17HMR.
When they started development on the round, they used the .20 grain bullet. It was inaccurate, so development stopped. One engineer was obsessed with it, and went to 17 grain, .17 cal and it became a tack driver.
It stayed with the 17 grain for several years, but people were disappointed with the performance on bigger game like coyotes.
Hornady re-engineered the design of the bullet, putting it back to 20 grains, but making the ogive or something different. Its a tack driver as well, but a better constructed bullet to take larger game like a coyote.
The original 17 grain is still available......for putting little critters to sleep.

This is an example from last fall. We have lots of extra veggies in the garden, and are used for targets sometimes.
This Squash was shot at 20 yds with the 17 grain Hornady. As you can see, there is not even a speck of lead, or jacket. It disintegrates into powder. Very little penetration.

DSC00630.jpg


Ok, off my podium now :rolleyes:
 
Who did you order it from? I've been checking the local wally world and they don't and never will have it......they don't......I'd better stop here.....

BTW there may be a new gun shop in Ponca? I've just heard the rumor in the last hour...... More to come..... :D
 
BassPro. http://www.basspro.com/Hornady--17-HMR-20gr-XTP-Rimfire-Ammo/product/82326/-1254202
$13.99 a box I know it not a great deal but they are running a 6 months to pay special for orders over $125 so I took advantage of that.


CheaperthanDirt has it for $10.25 a box
 
the new Hornady 20 grain is what to use for anything bigger than a Raccoon.


Hornady re-engineered the design of the bullet, putting it back to 20 grains, but making the ogive or something different. Its a tack driver as well, but a better constructed bullet to take larger game like a coyote.
The original 17 grain is still available......for putting little critters to sleep.

Nice kill on the squash! :D

On the 17 gr VMax:
It is highly frangible. Shoot a paper target backed by plywood and you'll see where the tiny fragments splash back from the surface of the wood, leaving pinholes in the paper from the backside.
Hitting anything disintegrates the bullet.
I found where I had hit a sumac branch the size of my little finger squarely. It left the complete jacket wadded up on my side of the wood, while the rest of the bullet punched through.
This little round is safer than any .22 round for plinking because of this. Out of thousands of rounds that I've fired, I have never seen any evidence of a ricochet.
It is the perfect round for turtles in a pond.

On the 20 gr XTP:
This is all I shoot anymore. It is still highly frangible, but does hold together when penetrating soft flesh.

A ricochet results in fragments of less than 20 grains which have been scrubbed of speed and energy. I still feel this round is safer than .22 lr.


As for killing coyotes with it, I recommend head shots on stationary animals. Some people have had luck with heart/lung shots, but to me, the risk of the bullet deflecting off of a rib with non fatal results is there.
I know that people have had great results with hogs, making ear/neck shots. I haven't had the opportunity to try that yet.
On coons I have had many one shot kills through the body. Most of those were on treed animals.

I prefer head shots on anything that size or larger. The accuracy, bullet construction, and energy of the XTP has given me great results in that application. I have yet to lose an animal.

As you pointed out previously, when the little HMR comes out, animals die in a big way. :D
 
My marlin 917 was the 1st rifle I bought for myself went in looking for a .22 magnum and the dealer talked me in to it and said if I dont like it he will do and even exchange for the gun I came in to buy. that was 4 years ago and I still shoot my .17hmr every time I go shooting and I has taken more game than any of my other hunting rifles.
 
I have a marlin 17vs. Strangely I havent had a chance to shoot it yet. I have shot plenty of 17 hmr's and i love the caliber. Far more deadly than any 22 mag IMO
 
Just did a transfer yesterday for a Henry 17 lever action; very sweet rifle; might have to consider getting one for myself
 
Back
Top