Springfield Emissary Commander .45 vs S&W Scandium E PC Commander

[Konko]

I am trying to decide between the Springfield Emissary 4.25" or the S&W PC E scandium .45 Commander. Have read many "pros" reviews, but I trust more the honest opinion of the laics that deal and edc them every day. Any help will be appreciated, thanks in advance.

 

[Mike D]

I have a 4.25 Emissary, in .45. I can't say enough for this thing! Out of the box, it was accurate as hell. Paper targets, plates at 25 yards., whatever, I was amazed. I put about 350 rds. through that thing on range day one. Not a single problem. If that Commander is anything like mine, I don't see how you can go wrong. Just a joy to shoot. A little too heavy for edc, but that's just me. Good luck with your choice!